Please minister, let’s have no data centres here
Dear Minister Helen Conway Ottenheimer:
I am writing as a constituent about AI data centres in our province. After comments from techNL’s CEO that the province should look into hosting one, and that other provinces are offering attractive deals, I want to be clear: I oppose an AI data centre anywhere in Newfoundland and Labrador, and I am asking you to oppose one in government.
The environmental costs are well documented. The International Energy Agency projects that global data centre electricity demand will more than double by 2030. A study by MIT researchers on how data centres affect communities reports that cooling and power generation strain regional water supplies, that on-site diesel backup generators add air pollution linked to cardiovascular and respiratory health risks, and that open land and green space near homes is converted into data centre campuses. The authors focus on Northern Virginia’s “Data Center Valley,” but the pattern is worth taking seriously before we invite one here.
Our own grid is already under strain. In December 2023, Newfoundland Power told the Public Utilities Board that supply risk on the island was elevated and that Hydro is significantly capacity-constrained, which CBC reported as a risk to any new customer seeking firm capacity. Hydro is also still relying on aging backup plants, and the Holyrood station was meant to close once Muskrat Falls came online but remains in service because of reliability concerns about the Labrador-Island Link. A facility with the power demands of an AI data centre would land on a system that is already stretched.
You represent rural communities outside of major urban centres, and the same study notes that data centres are increasingly built in residential and semi-rural areas. Its authors found that the tax benefits go mainly to governments and utilities and often do not reach the surrounding community, while grid upgrade costs are frequently passed on to residential customers. Residents live with the strain on water, power and land, while the companies behind these facilities are far removed from the consequences.
Newfoundland and Labrador also depends on tourism, and visitors come for our coastline, wilderness and outdoor culture. If we trade that landscape for industrial development, we put at risk the very thing that draws people here and that those of us who live here value.
I ask that you oppose any AI data centre in this province. At the very least, I ask that no incentives be offered without a public, independent assessment of water, power and community impacts.
Sincerely,
Claire Morris,
Seal Cove, CBS

